Back to Blog

This Time It Is Different

Written by Amit Shah®December 09, 20243 min read

I still remember a conversation I had with a friend, let’s call him Arun, back in late 1999. Arun had just doubled his savings in a matter of months, all thanks to internet stocks—companies that few had heard of a year before but now seemed destined to change the world. Everywhere we looked, media headlines and expert panels on TV hammered one message home: “The internet has transformed everything. This time, it really is different.”

It wasn’t different. Months later, the Dot-Com bubble burst. Arun’s portfolio, once a proud symbol of easy riches, sank like a stone. As I reflect on Arun’s story—and countless others like it over the decades—a familiar pattern emerges.

What Drives the “This Time Is Different” Mindset?

  • Overconfidence Fuelled by Rising Prices: When markets go up consistently, it’s tempting to think that your success is a direct result of skill rather than a bull market’s tailwinds.

  • Media and Echo Chambers: News outlets, social media influencers, and fellow investors often reinforce optimistic narratives. Positive coverage feeds on itself, creating the illusion of a new era.

  • Ignoring Fundamentals: In the frenzy, traditional valuation metrics and risk warnings fall by the wayside. If everyone else seems to be getting rich, it must be safe, right?

  • Confirmation Bias: We actively seek information that supports our bullish stance. Contrarian voices are dismissed as outdated or pessimistic.

Real-Life Examples of Past Bull Markets

  • The Roaring Twenties:
    In the late 1920s, newspapers proclaimed a permanent plateau of prosperity. Ordinary folks mortgaged their homes to buy stocks on margin. When the 1929 crash hit, fortunes evaporated overnight.

  • The Dot-Com Bubble (Late 1990s):
    Nightly news segments championed the “new economy.” Valuations skyrocketed on hype and projected future earnings, not present cash flow. When reality set in, the Nasdaq lost over 70% of its value.

  • The U.S. Housing Bubble (Mid-2000s):
    Magazines and talk shows pushed the narrative that real estate never goes down. Complex financial products “reduced” risk, or so the media said. The 2008 crisis debunked that myth spectacularly.

  • Crypto and Meme Stocks (2020-2021):
    Social media influencers and YouTube personalities promised that digital currencies and meme stocks were changing the rules of investing. When the hype subsided, countless investors were left holding heavy losses.

How Media Clouds Investors’ Psychology

  • 24/7 News Cycles: Constant streams of headlines, tweets, and opinion pieces make it hard to think independently.

  • Selective Coverage: Bullish markets generate exciting stories. Bad news is often downplayed or spun into a buying opportunity.

  • Influencer Authority: Charismatic personalities online present themselves as visionaries. Their confidence becomes contagious, leading investors to follow blindly.

From Euphoria to Bust: Why Does the Bubble Burst?

  • Unsustainable Valuations: At some point, prices become so detached from underlying fundamentals that a correction is inevitable.

  • Catalytic Events: Interest rate hikes, regulatory shifts, disappointing earnings, or even a poorly-timed tweet can pop a fragile bubble.

  • Panic Selling: Once selling starts, fear takes over. Media headlines flip from “it’s different this time” to “the world is ending,” intensifying the downturn.

How to Protect Yourself: Risk Management and Core Philosophy

  • Set Clear Investment Principles: Know your long-term goals and stick to them. Don’t let short-term euphoria derail you.

  • Diversify: Spread your investments across asset classes, sectors, and geographies to reduce the impact of a single downturn.

  • Regular Portfolio Reviews: Check if your holdings still align with your thesis. Has the story changed? Are valuations rational?

  • Ignore the Noise: Turn off the TV when it becomes sensationalist. Limit social media exposure. Rely on analytical tools and reputable sources over hype.

  • Prepare for Corrections: Understand that every bull run eventually faces headwinds. Planning for a downturn, before it happens, is what separates wise investors from the rest.

A Better Mindset: Embracing Historical Perspective
Arun’s story from the Dot-Com era isn’t unique. There’s always someone who believes that this time is different, that the old rules no longer apply. History shows that it rarely is. Instead of chasing the next big thing at all costs, learn to recognize market mania for what it is—human nature playing out in real-time.

By cultivating a disciplined approach, acknowledging our own biases, and remembering that no trend lasts forever, we can enjoy the benefits of a bull market without being swallowed whole when sentiment turns. Long-term wealth isn’t built by joining the chorus of “this time is different” but by tempering hope with hard-earned wisdom and steadfast principles.

Share this Article
Back to Blog